Analysis of Brian Reese Article: York County militia supporter’s request for info on district employees spurs policy change

Location: York County, VA
Author: Brian Reese, Digital Producer, WAVY.com news organization
Date: 22 February, 2024
Title: York County militia supporter’s request for info on district employees spurs policy change

• Key Points:
  • A supporter of a local militia in York County requested names and schools of teachers opposing the county’s new right-wing school board.
  • The request followed public criticisms by staff and community members on January 29.
    Superintendent Victor Shandor expressed concern for staff safety and addressed the request during a February 12 work session.
  • A policy was revised to protect speaker privacy at board meetings, removing the requirement to provide home addresses.
  • Gary Porter, identified as the requester, is linked to the York County Poquoson Constitutional Militia (YCPCM).
  • The policy revision aims to shield staff from defamation and intimidation linked to board member associates.
  • Board Chair Lynda Fairman supported the privacy policy change, citing personal safety concerns from past experiences.
  • The board unanimously approved the policy change on February 12.
  • Porter, who requested the information, is a retired Air Force veteran and denied acting on behalf of board members, though he admitted to knowing them.
  • Fairman denied association with the YCPCM, while Porter described himself as a supporter, not a member, of the militia.
  • Further discussions on recent events are scheduled for a school board meeting on February 26.
• Political Analysis of the WAVY 10 Article (from the perspective of the written words in the article):
  • Victor Shandor: York County Superintendent, voiced concerns regarding staff safety in response to the FOIA request for names and schools of certain teachers, advocating for policy changes to protect staff privacy and security.
  • Gary Porter: Supporter of the “York County Poquoson Constitutional Militia (YCPCM)” and the individual who filed the FOIA request. He is an Air Force veteran and retired Lockheed Martin employee, denied acting on behalf of the school board members but acknowledged a personal relationship with them.
  • Lynda Fairman: Board Chair of the York County School Board, faced allegations of ordering the filming of a Family Life Education event by the group associated with Porter. She supported the policy change to enhance privacy and safety for individuals speaking at board meetings.
  • Kimberly Goodwin: Vice Chair of the York County School Board, mentioned as having a relationship with Gary Porter, who considers her a friend.
  • Zoran Pajevic: Member of the York County School Board, also mentioned as having a relationship with Gary Porter.

This Political Analysis outlines the individuals that author Brian Reese identified as involved in the controversy surrounding the York County School Board, highlighting their roles and connections. Brian Reese attempts to develop previously unidentified and contentious issues to amplify them around privacy, safety, and the influence of local militia support within the educational and political landscape of York County.

• Political Bias Analysis of the WAVY 10 Article:
  Identifying political bias solely from the provided information means that the author (Brian Reese) establishes (whether real or not) roles, actions, and affiliations of the individuals involved. Based on the context of the situation involving the York County School Board, Reese establishes the key figures with potential indications of their political or ideological leanings:
  • Gary Porter:
    Bias: Right-wing or conservative, suggested by his support for a local militia group identified as the “York County Poquoson Constitutional Militia (YCPCM)” and his actions targeting teachers opposed to the new right-wing school board leadership.
  • York County School Board Leadership (not individually named except for Lynda Fairman):
    Bias: Right-wing or conservative, inferred from the description as “new right-wing school board leadership” and the controversies surrounding their actions and policies since taking office.
  • Lynda Fairman (Board Chair):
    Bias: Potentially right-wing or conservative, based on allegations of ordering a group to film a Family Life Education event and her association with Gary Porter and the militia group. Her support for the policy change to protect speaker privacy could be seen as a response to safety concerns rather than a direct indication of political bias.
  • Victor Shandor (York County Superintendent):
    Bias: Non-specific, as his actions and statements focus on staff safety and policy changes in response to concerns about privacy and intimidation. His role as superintendent places him in a position where he must navigate political tensions while maintaining a commitment to the safety and well-being of staff and students.
  • Kimberly Goodwin and Zoran Pajevic (School Board Members):
    Bias: Possible right-wing or conservative affiliations, suggested by their association with Gary Porter, who explicitly supports the local militia and the right-wing board leadership.

The Political Bias analysis of this article suggests that the author (Brian Reese) is developing a case for dividing the the York County educational and political community, by highlighting a singular ideological perspective of certain individuals. Perspectives and developed language in the article indicate that school board leadership is displaying tendencies or actions that align with right-wing or conservative ideologies, particularly in the context of educational policy and community engagement.

• Perception Analysis of the WAVY TV 10 Article:
  A perception analysis examines how the actions and affiliations of individuals within the York County School Board controversy might be viewed by different segments of the community or the public. This analysis considers the perspectives that various stakeholders might hold based on the described events and interactions.
  • Victor Shandor:
    Perceived as a protector of educational staff and advocate for safety and privacy, especially in his role as Superintendent responding to concerns about staff being targeted due to their opposition to the new school board leadership.
  • Gary Porter:
    Viewed positively by supporters of the local militia and those favoring strong conservative measures within the school system, as someone standing up for their beliefs and seeking accountability from school staff.
    Seen negatively by critics of the militia and opponents of the new school board leadership, who may view his actions as intimidating or threatening towards educational staff.
  • Lynda Fairman (Board Chair):
    Perceived by supporters as proactive and concerned for individual safety and privacy, particularly in light of her support for policy changes to protect speakers at board meetings.
    Viewed skeptically by opponents who might see her alleged actions and affiliations with militia-supporting groups as indicative of a desire to push a specific political agenda within the education system.
  • Kimberly Goodwin and Zoran Pajevic (School Board Members):
    Seen by allies and like-minded community members as part of a necessary change within the school board, possibly bringing a fresh, if controversial, perspective to educational governance.
    Perceived by detractors as potentially contributing to a divisive or hostile educational environment, especially if their association with figures like Gary Porter and militia groups is seen as influencing their policy decisions.

This analysis indicates that the author Brian Reese is attempting to establish a polarized perception of the individuals involved, largely influenced by the broader political and ideological divides within the community. The author points out that actions such as requesting the names of opposing teachers, supporting militia groups, and implementing policy changes for safety and privacy can be interpreted in vastly different ways, depending on one’s political alignment, values, and concerns for the local education system.

• Sentiment Analysis of the WAVY 10 news article:
  A sentiment analysis based on the context of the article by Brian Reese regarding the York County School Board situation focuses on the emotions, attitudes, and tones conveyed by or associated with the individuals and groups mentioned and communicated to the general public. The sentiments identified are meant to appeal to activist groups who are planning disruptions online, on social media, at school board meetings, and to individual school board members.
  • Victor Shandor (York County Superintendent):
    Sentiment: Concerned and protective. He expressed significant concern for the safety and privacy of staff members in light of the FOIA request, advocating for policy changes to enhance security.
  • Gary Porter:
    Sentiment: Defensive but proactive. Porter confirmed his action of requesting information on school employees but clarified his intentions were not malicious. He seemed to defend his right to information while denying broader accusations of acting on behalf of the school board members.
  • Lynda Fairman (Board Chair):
    Sentiment: Supportive of privacy and safety measures, reflecting a proactive stance on protecting community members’ privacy. Despite allegations against her, her support for the policy change suggests a concern for safety and privacy.
  • Community Members and School Staff:
    Sentiment: Displeased and concerned. The actions of the new school board leadership prompted dissatisfaction among some community members and staff, leading to public expressions of displeasure.
  • York County Poquoson Constitutional Militia (YCPCM):
    Sentiment: Implicitly aggressive or confrontational, as inferred from the concerns raised about the militia’s supporter requesting personal information of school staff. Although not directly quoted, the context suggests the group’s presence and actions may contribute to a tense atmosphere.
    The author Brian Reese changed the name of the York County Poquson Community Missions (YCPCM) to York County Poquson Constitutional Militia.
  • School Board Members (Kimberly Goodwin and Zoran Pajevic mentioned):
    Sentiment: Unclear but implicated in controversy. While not directly expressing sentiments in the article, their association with Porter and the board’s controversial decisions suggest they are central to the ongoing tensions.

This sentiment analysis reveals that the author Brian Reese is attempting to establish a landscape of concern, defensiveness, and proactive measures in response to perceived threats to privacy and safety within the York County School Board and its community. The situation is marked by a complex interplay of intentions, actions, and reactions among the involved parties.

READ ARTICLE